有人/无人机协同作战：概念、技术与挑战

doi:10.7527/S1000-6893.2023.29653

Abstract

Abstract: In view of the current situation of the future battlefield, such as high complexity of the environment, strong antagonism of the game, high real-time response, information incomplete, and boundary uncertainty, manned/unmanned cooperative combat system can become the core key to win the future and space battlefield by means of its advantages of superposition release of effectiveness, complementarities of combat weaknesses and high efficiency of action coordination. This paper focuses on the research status of manned/unmanned cooperative combat. It is a new direction of high difficulty, rapid development, broad application prospect and multidisciplinary combat. The research status of manned/unmanned cooperative combat is summarized from three aspects: system concept, key technologies and challenges. It focuses on the definition of system combat, winning mechanism and application process. The key technologies such as detection and situational awareness, mission planning, command and decision making, formation control, and effectiveness evaluation are expounded. Finally, the challenges to be solved in the future battlefield of manned/unmanned cooperative combat are analyzed. It provides new development ideas for future intelligent combat technology.

Key words: Manned/unmanned systems, Project verification, Detection and situational awareness, Task planning, Command decision, Formation control, Effectiveness evaluation

CLC Number:

V279
E91

References

[1] Zhong Y, Yao P Y , Zhang J Y, et al. Formation and adjustment of manned/unmanned combat aerial vehicle cooperative engagement system[J]. Journal of Systems Engineering and Electronics,2018,29(4): 756-767.
[2] Richard C M, Leila Hashemi, Armin Mahmoodi, et al. Integrating unmanned and manned UAVs data network based on combined Bayesian belief network and multi-objective reinforcement learning algorithm[J]. Drone Systems and Applica-tions,2023,11:1-17.
[3] 李飞,王世梅,吕永健,等.智能化对未来空中作战的重塑——有人无人协同空中作战制胜机理[J].军事文摘,2022,517(13):21-24.
LI F, WANG S M, LV Y J, et al. The reconstruction of intelligence for future air combat: Winning mechanism of man-unmanned cooperative air combat [J]. Journal of Military Abstracts, 2019,517(13):21-24. (in Chinese)
[4] Paul Tobias, Braemer Emanuel. Operational Considerations for Teaming Manned and Unmanned Helicopter[J]. Journal of Intelligent & Robotic Systems,2013,69(1-4):33-40.
[5] STEFAN G，BENJAMIN L，AXEL S．Management of multiple unmanned combat aerial vehicles from a singleseat fighter cockpit in manned-unmanned fighter missions[C]// Proc of Guidance，Navigation，Control and Colocated Conferences. Boston: AIAA, 2013:4899-4907.
[6] 张宏宏,甘旭升,李双峰,等.复杂低空环境下考虑区域风险评估的无人机航路规划[J].仪器仪表学报,2021,42(01):257-266.
ZHANG H H, GAN X S, LI S F, et al. UAV route planning considering regional risk assessment under complex low-altitude environment [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific Instrument, 2021,42(01):257-266. (in Chinese)
[7] 丁达理,陈龙斌,周欢.有人/无人机智能协同作战正在崛起[N].解放军报,2020-03-05(7).
DING D L, CHEN L B, ZHOU H. Manned/UAV intel-ligent cooperative combat is rising [N]. PLA Dai-ly,2020-03-05(7). (in Chinese)
[8] 贾珍珍,丁宁,陈方舟.智能化战争加速到来[N].解放军报,2022-03-17(11).
JIA Z Z, DING N, CHEN F Z. Intelligent warfare ac-celerates [N]. PLA Daily,2022-03-17(11). (in Chinese)
[9] 王琳,辛冀,高超.有人/无人协同作战中直升机的作用分析[J].直升机技术,2021(01):63-67.
WANG L, XIN J, GAO C. Analysis of the Roles of Helicopters in MUM-T [J]. Helicopter Technolo-gy,2021(01):63-67. (in Chinese)
[10] 张宏宏,甘旭升,孙静娟, 等.基于STPA-TOPAZ的低空无人机冲突解脱安全性分析[J].航空学报,2022,43(07):262-274.
ZHANG H H, GAN X S, SUN J J, et al. Analysis of low altitude UAV conflict resolution safety based on STPA-TOPAZ[J]. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica, 2022,43(07):262-274. (in Chinese)
[11] Wang D L, Shao Q Q, Yue H Y. Surveying Wild Animals from Satellites, Manned Aircraft and Unmanned Aerial Systems (UASs): A Review[J]. Remote Sensing. 2019; 11(11):1308.
[12] 张宏宏,甘旭升,毛亿,等.无人机避障算法综述[J].航空兵器,2021,28(05):53-63.
ZHANG H H, GAN X S, MAO Y, et al. Review of UAV Obstacle Avoidance Algorithms[J]. Aero Weaponry,2021,28(5):53-63. (in Chinese)
[13] Fu L, Liu J, Meng G, et al. Survey Of Manned/Unmanned Air Combat Decision Technolo-gy[C]//27th Chinese Control and Decision Conference (CCDC), China,2015:360-364.
[14] Button K. Manned-unmanned teaming[J]. Aerospace America,2014,52(5):36-41.
[15] 牛轶峰,沈林成,李杰等.无人–有人机协同控制关键问题[J].中国科学:信息科学,2019,49(05):538-554.
NIU Y F, SHEN L C, LI J, et al. Key scientific prob-lems in cooperation control of unmanned-manned aircraft systems[J]. Sci Sin Inform,2019, 49: 538–554. (in Chinese)
[16] ZHONG Y, YAO P Y, SUN Y, et al. Research on command and control of MAV/UAV engagement from the cooperative perspective[C]//International Conference on Information System and Artificial Intelligence (ISAI), Hong Kong, China,2016:38-44.
[17] Gaydos S J, Curry I P. Manned-Unmanned Teaming: Expanding the Envelope of UAS Operational Employment[J]. Aviation Space and Environmental Medicine,2014,85(12): 1231-1232.
[18] Hu X, Yang L Y, Zhang J. The design and analysis of hierarchical decision-making for manned/unmanned cooperative engagement[C]//34th Chinese Control Conference (CCC), Hangzhou, China, 2015: 2698-2703.
[19] 刘树光,王欢.有人/无人机协同编队控制研究综述[J].飞行力学,2022,40(05):1-8.
LIU S G, WANG H. Review of Research on cooperative formation control for manned/unmanned aerial vehicles[J]. Flight Dynamics,2022,40(05):1-8. (in Chinese)
[20] HENRIQUES J F, CASEIRO R, MARTINS P, et al. Exploiting the circulant structure of tracking-by-detection with kernels[C]//European Conference on Computer Vision. 2012: 702-715.
[21] Shalaby M, Shokair M, Messiha N W. Performance Enhancement of TOA Localized Wireless Sensor Networks[J]. Wireless Personal Communications,2017,95(4): 4667-4679.
[22] Herath S C K, Pathirana P N. Robust Localization With Minimum Number of TDoA Measurements[J]. IEEE Signal Processing Letters,2013,20(10):949-951.
[23] Ding X H, Dong S. Improving Positioning Algorithm Based on RSSI[J]. Wireless Personal Communications,2020,110(4):1947-1961.
[24] Wang C X, Fu W X, Zhang T, et al. An AOA Optimal Positioning Method Incorporating Station Error and Sensor Deployment[J]. Aero-space,2022,9(12):766.
[25] 李樾,韩维,陈清阳,等.有人/无人机协同系统的目标定位方法[J].华中科技大学学报(自然科学版),2019,47(08):18-22.
LI Y, HAN Wi, CHEN Q Y, et al. Positioning approach based on cooperative system of manned/unmanned aerial vehicles[J]. Journal of Huazhong University of Science and Technology (Natural Science Edi-tion),2019,47(08):18-22. (in Chinese)
[26] Bulusu N, Heidemann J, Estrin D. GPS-less low-cost outdoor localization for very small devices[J]. IEEE Personal Communications, 2000,7(5): 28–34.
[27] Niculescu D, Nath B. DV based positioning in ad hoc networks[J]. Telecommunication Systems,2003, 22 (1): 267–280.
[28] Cerpa A, Estrin D. ASCENT. Adaptive self-configuring sensor networks topologies[J]. IEEE Transactions on Mobile Computing, 2004, 3 (3): 272–285.
[29] Chen X, Li Y A, Li Y X, et al. A Novel Probabilistic Data Association for Target Tracking in a Cluttered Environment[J]. Sensors,2017,16(12):2180.
[30] Kalkan Y, Baykal B. Multiple target localization & data association for frequency-only widely separated MIMO radar[J]. Digital Signal Pro-cessing,2014,25:51-61.
[31] Liu C L, Shan L, Chen Y Y, et al. Average-Consensus Filter of First-Order Multi-Agent Systems With Disturbances[J]. IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems II: Express Briefs, 2018,65 (11):1763–1767.
[32] PENG H，ZHANG Y，YANG S，et al. Battlefield image situational awareness application based on deep learning[J]. IEEE Intelligent Systems, 2020, 35(1):36-43.
[33] Zhang Y S, Pan M H, Long W J, et al. Joint waveform selection and power allocation algorithm in manned/unmanned aerial vehicle hybrid swarm based on chance-constraint programming[J]. Journal of Sys-tems Engineering and Electronics,2022,33(3): 551-562.
[34] 刘跃峰,陈哨东,赵振宇,等.基于FBNs的有人机/UCAV编队对地攻击威胁评估[J].系统工程与电子技术,2012,34(08):1635-1639.
LIU Y F, CHEN S D, ZHAO Z Y, et al. Threat assess-ment of manned/unmanned combat aerial vehicle for-mation air-to-ground attack based on FBNs[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics,2012,34(08):1635-1639. (in Chinese)
[35] 韩博文,姚佩阳,钟赟,等.基于QABC-IFMADM算法的有人/无人机编队作战威胁评估[J].电子学报,2018,46(07):1584-1592.
HAN B W, YAO P Y, ZHANG Y, et al. Threat assess-ment of manned/unmanned aerial vehicle formation based on QABC-IFMADM algorithm[J]. Acta Elec-tronica Sinica,2018,46(07):1584-1592. (in Chinese)
[36] Xu T, Chen Y Z, Wang Y M, et al. EMI Threat Assessment of UAV Data Link Based on Multi-Task CNN[J]. Electronics,2023,12(7): 1631.
[37] Zhong Y, Yao PY, Sun Y, et al. Cooperative task allocation method of MCAV/UCAV formation[J]. Mathematical Problems in Engineering, 2016, 2016: 6051046.
[38] JIA Z Y, YU J Q, AI X L, et al. Cooperative multiple task assignment problem with stochastic velocities and time windows for heterogeneous unmanned aerial vehicles using a genetic algorithm[J]. Aerospace Science and Technology, 2018, 76: 112-125.
[39] JIAO Z Q, YAO P Y, ZHANG J Y. MAV/UAV task coalition phased-formation method[J] Journal of Systems Engineering and Electron-ics,2019,30(02):402-414.
[40] Li B, Wang Y X, Zhang Y B, et al. Cooperative task assignment algorithm of manned/unmanned aerial vehicle in uncertain environment[C]// Proceedings of 2017 IEEE 2nd Information Technology, Networking, Electronic and Automation Control Conference (ITNEC 2017), Chengdu,2017: 1154-1158.
[41] 韩博文,姚佩阳.基于Holon组织的有人/无人机作战联盟形成[J].系统工程与电子技术,2018,40(01):91-97.
HAN B W, YAO P Y. Coalition formation of manned/unmanned aerial vehicle cluster based on Holon organization[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics,2018,40(01):91-97. (in Chinese)
[42] CHEN Y B, YANG D, YUJ Q. Multi-UAV Task Assignment with Parameter and Time-Sensitive Uncertainties Using Modified Two-Part Wolf Pack Search Algorithm[J]. IEEE Transactions on Aerospace and Electronic Systems, 2018, 54(6):2853-2872.
[43] 刘跃峰,张安.有人机/无人机编队协同任务分配方法[J].系统工程与电子技术,2010,32(03):584-588.
LIU Y F, ZHANG A. Collaborative task assignment method of manned/unmanned aerial vehicle for-mation[J]. Systems Engineering and Electron-ics,2010,32(03):584-588. (in Chinese)
[44] Liu Y F, Zou J, Sun H J. Task allocation method of manned/unmanned aerial vehicle formation based on extended CNP// 2016 IEEE Chinese Guidance, Navigation and Control Conference (CGNCC), Nanjing: IEEE,2016: 1975–1979.
[45] 万路军,姚佩阳,孙鹏.有人/无人作战智能体分布式任务分配方法[J].系统工程与电子技术,2013,35(02):310-316.
WAN L J, YAO P Y, SUN P. Distributed task assign-ment method for manned/unmanned combat agents[J]. Systems Engineering and Electron-ics,2013,35(02):310-316. (in Chinese)
[46] 万路军,姚佩阳,周翔翔,等.有人/无人作战智能体分布式协同目标分配方法[J].系统工程与电子技术,2014,36(02):278-287.
WAN L J, YAO P Y, ZHOU X X, et al. Distributed co-operative target assignment method for manned/unmanned combat agents [J]. Systems Engi-neering and Electronics,2014,36(02):278-287. (in Chinese)
[47] Wang C, Wen X P, Niu Y F, et al. Dynamic Task Allocation for Heterogeneous Manned-unmanned Aerial Vehicle Teamwork[C]// 2018 Chinese Automation Congress (CAC), Xi'an, China, 2018:3345-3349.
[48] LI Y, HAN W, ZHANG Y, et al. Trajectory Planning Based on Spatial-Temporal Constraints for MAV/UAV Cooperative System[C]// 第三十八届中国控制会议,Guangzhou,2019:959-964.
[49] 李樾,韩维,陈清阳,等.凸优化算法在有人/无人机协同系统航迹规划中的应用[J].宇航学报,2020,41(03):276-286.
LI Y, HAN W, CHEN Q Y, et al. Application of con-vex optimization algorithm in trajectory planning of manned /unmanned cooperative System[J]. Journal of Astronautics,2020,41(03):276-286. (in Chinese)
[50] Schousenaars T, Valenti M, Feron E, et al. Linear programming and language processing for hu-man/unmanned-aerial-vehicle team missions[J]. Journal of Guidance, Control, and Dynamics, 2006, 29(2):303-313.
[51] Fan J R, Li D G, Li R P. Research on Mission Planning for MAV/UAV Cooperative Combat[C]// 2019 IEEE International Conference on Unmanned Systems (ICUS), Beijing,2019: 548-553.
[52] Fan J R, un H Y, Sun X, et al. Mission Planning of MAV/UAV Cooperative Combat based on Improved Genetic Algorithm[C]//2021 China Automation Congress (CAC), Beijing,2021: 3264-3269.
[53] Kou K H, Yu J Y, Wang G, et al. Task assignment and route planning method of cooperative attack for manned/unmanned aerial vehicles[C]// 2017 IEEE International Conference on Unmanned Systems (ICUS), Beijing,2017: 168-176.
[54] 罗维尔,魏瑞轩.有人/无人机协同打击航路智能规划[J].控制理论与应用,2019,36(07):1090-1095.
LUO W R, WEI R X. Intelligent route planning for cooperative striking of manned/unmanned aerial vehicle [J]. Control Theory & Applica-tions,2019,36(07):1090-1095. (in Chinese)
[55] 李樾,韩维,陈清阳,等.基于改进的速度障碍法的有人/无人机协同系统三维实时避障方法[J].西北工业大学学报,2020,38(02):309-318.
LI Y, HAN W, CHEN Q Y, et al. Real-time obstacle avoidance for manned /unmanned aircraft cooperative system based on improved velocity ob-stacle method[J]. Journal of Northwestern Polytechnical University, 2019,38(02):309-318. (in Chinese)
[56] Yan Y J, Wang H J, Chen X F. Collaborative Path Planning based on MAXQ Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning for Manned/Unmanned Aerial Vehicles[C]// 2020 39th Chinese Control Conference (CCC), Shenyang,2020: 4837-4842.
[57] Shi G, H?nig W, Shi X, et al. Neural-swarm2: Planning and control of heterogeneous multirotor swarms using learned interactions Intelligent route planning for cooperative striking of manned/unmanned aerial vehicle IEEE Transactions on Robotics,2021,38(2): 1063-1079.
[58] 陈军,张新伟,徐嘉,等.有人/无人机混合编队有限干预式协同决策[J].航空学报,2015,36(11):3652-3665.
CHEN J, ZHANG X W, XU J, et al. Human/unmanned-aerial-vehicle team collaborative decision-making with limited intervention[J]. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica,2015,36(11):3652-3665. (in Chinese)
[59] 钟赟,姚佩阳,孙昱.有人机/UCAV编队协同作战决策分配方法[J].系统工程理论与实践,2016,36(11):2984-2992.
ZHONG Y, YAO P Y, Sun Y. Decision-making alloca-tion method in manned/unmanned combat aerial vehicle cooperative engagement[J]. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice, 2016, 36(11): 2984-2992. (in Chinese)
[60] 钟赟,姚佩阳,张杰勇,等.基于HFCM的有人-无人机作战系统交互式协同决策[J].系统工程理论与实践,2021,41(10):2748-2760.
ZHONG Y, YAO P Y, ZHANG J Y, et al. Interactive cooperative decision-making of manned-unmanned aerial vehicle combat system based on HFCM[J]. Systems Engineering- Theory & Practice, 2021, 41(10): 2748-2760. (in Chinese)
[61] Chen J, Xu J, Ding L, et al. Limited intervention collaborative decision-making of MAV/UAV team based on FCM[C]//Proceedings of 2016 IEEE International Conference on Signal Processing, Communications and Computing (ICSPCC), Hong Kong, 2016,1-6.
[62] Chen J, Xu J, Zhong L H. Limited intervention collaborative decision making of MAV-UAV team based on VFCM[C]//Proceedings of 2016 IEEE International Conference on Services Computing (SCC), San Francisco, CA, USA, 2016,876-879.
[63] Li Y, Han W, Wang Y Q, et al. Deep Reinforcement Learning With Application to Air Confrontation Intelligent Decision-Making of Manned/Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Cooperative System[J]. IEEE Access,2020,8: 67887 – 67898.
[64] Li Y, Han W, Zhong W G, et al. Intelligent Decision-Making of MAV/UAV in Air Combat Based on DDPG Algorithm//Proceedings of 2020 International Conference on Guidance, Navigation and Control, ICGNC 2020, Tianjin, Chi-na,2020: 4881–4891.
[65] ZHONG Y, YAO P Y, WAN L J, et al. Intervention decision-making in MAV/UAV cooperative engagement based on human factors engineering[J]. Journal of Systems Engineering and Electronics,2018,29(3): 530–538.
[66] 吴立尧,韩维,张勇,等.基于领航-跟随的有人/无人机编队队形保持控制[J].控制与决策,2021,36(10):2435-2441.
WU L Y, HAN W, ZHANG Y, et al. Formation keep-ing control of manned/unmanned aerial vehicle formation based on leader-follower strategy[J]. Control and Decision, 2019,36(10):2435-2441. (in Chinese)
[67] Han Z M, Guo K X, Xie L H, et al. Integrated Relative Localization and Leader-Follower Formation Control[J]. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control,2019,64(1):20-34.
[68] Nguyen X M, Hong S K. Robust adaptive formation control of quadcopters based on a leader-follower approach[J]. International Journal of Advanced Robotic Systems,2019,16(4): 1729881419862733.
[69] Kong S L, Yu XQ. A Leader-Follower Control Strategy for Input-Delay Stochastic Systems[J]. IEEE Access,2022,10: 36629-36636.
[70] Ali Z A, Israr A, Alkhammash E H, et al. A Leader-Follower Formation Control of Multi-UAVs via an Adaptive Hybrid Controller[J]. Complexity,2021,2021: 9231636.
[71] Wang B L, Duan X J, Yan L, et al. Rapidly Tuning the PID Controller Based on the Regional Surrogate Model Technique in the UAV Formation[J]. Entropy,2020,22(5): 527.
[72] SONG R Z, XING S, XU Z. Finite-time leader-follower consensus of a discrete-time system via sliding mode control[J]. Frontiers of Information Technology & Electronic Engineering,2022,23(7): 1057-1068.
[73] 王晶,顾维博,窦立亚.基于Leader-Follower的多无人机编队轨迹跟踪设计[J].航空学报,2020,41(S1):88-98.
WANG J. GU W B. DOU L Y. Leader-Follower for-mation control of multipte UAVs with trajectory tracking design[J]. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica. 2020. 41(S1): 723758. (in Chinese)
[74] Mario RAMIREZ-NERIA, JoséL GARCIA-ANTONIO, Hebertt J SIRA-RAMIREZ, et al. 领导者–跟随者Thomson跳环系统的自抗扰控制设计(英文)[J].控制理论与应用,2013,30(12):1564-1572.
[75] Chen Z Z, Yang J, Zong X J. Leader-follower synchronization controller design for a network of boundary-controlled wave PDEs with structured time-varying perturbations and general disturbances[J]. Journal of the Franklin Institute-Engineering and Applied Mathematics,2021,358(1): 834-855.
[76] Jasim W, Gu D B. Robust Team Formation Control for Quadrotors[J]. IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology,2018,26(4): 1516-1523.
[77] Yang K B, Dong W H, Tong Y Y, et al. Leader-follower Formation Consensus of Quadrotor UAVs Based on Prescribed Performance Adaptive Constrained Backstepping Control[J]. International Journal of Control, Automation, and Sys-tems,2022,20(10): 3138-3154.
[78] Hafez A T, Marasco A J, Givigi S N, et al. Solving Multi-UAV Dynamic Encirclement via Model Predictive Control[J]. IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology,23(6): 2251-2265.
[79] LI C J, LIU G P. Data-Driven Leader-Follower Output Synchronization for Networked Non-Linear Multi-Agent Systems with Switching Topology and Time-Varying Delays[J].Journal of Systems Science & Complexity,2018,31(01):87-102.
[80] 吴治海,彭力,谢林柏,等.Stochastic bounded consensus tracking of leader-follower multi-agent systems with measurement noises based on sampled data with general sampling delay[J].Chinese Physics B,2013,22(12):559-566.
[81] LIU Wenhui, YANG Chunjie, SUN Youxian,et al.Observer-Based Event-Triggered Tracking Control of Leader-Follower Systems with Time Delay[J].Journal of Systems Science & Complexity,2016,29(04):865-880.
[82] Liu Y A, Wang Q, Dong C Y, et al. Time-varying formation control for unmanned aerial vehicles with external disturbances[J].Transactions Of The Institute Of Measurement And Control,2019,41(13): 3777-3786.
[83] 陈世明,王明雨.带扰动混杂多智能体系统领导–跟随一致性[J].控制理论与应用,2020,37(07):1583-1588.
CHEN S M, WANG M Y. Leader-follower consensus of hybrid multi-agent systems with disturbances[J].Control Theory & Applications, 2020,37(07):1583-1588. (in Chinese)
[84] 张民,夏卫政,黄坤,等.基于Leader-Follower编队的无人机协同跟踪地面目标制导律设计[J].航空学报,2018,39(02):230-242.
ZHANG M, XIA W Z. HUANG K, et al. Guidance law for cooperative tracking of a ground target based on leader-follolwer formation of UAVs[J]. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica, 2018, 39(2), 321497. (in Chinese)
[85] LEWIS M A, TAN K H. High precision formation control of mobile robots using virtual structures [ J]. Autonomous Robots,1997(4):387-403.
[86] HE L L,BAI P,LIANG X L,et al. Feedback formation control of UAV swarm with multiple implicit leaders[J]. Aerospace Science and Tech-nology,2018,72:327-334.
[87] 吴立尧,韩维,张勇,等.基于人机合作的有人/无人机编队队形变换策略[J].系统工程与电子技术,2020,42(02):434-444.
WU L Y, HAN W, ZHANG Y, et al. Formation trans-formation strategy for manned/unmanned aerial vehicle formation based on human-machine cooperation[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics, 2020, 42(2):434-444. (in Chinese)
[88] Askari A, Mortazavi M, Talebi H A. UAV Formation Control via the Virtual Structure Approach[J]. Journal of Aerospace Engineering,2015,28(1): 04014047.
[89] Li P, Cao J, Liang D C. UAV-BS Formation Control Method Based on Loose Coupling Structure[J]. IEEE Access,2022, 10:88330-88339.
[90] Balch T, Arkin R C. Behavior-Based Formation Control for Multi-robot Teams[J]. IEEE Transactions on Robotics and Au-tomation,1998,14(6):926-939.
[91] Xu D D, Zhang X N, Zhu Z Q, et al. Behavior-Based Formation Control of Swarm Ro-bots,2014: 205759.
[92] Song P, Han X B, Li K J, et al. Behavior-based Formation Control of nodes of Mobile Sensor Network[J]. Information-An International Interdisciplinary Journal,2011,14(3): 917-923.
[93] Proetzsch M, Luksch T, Berns K. Development of complex robotic systems using the behavior-based control architecture iB2C[J]. Robotics and Autonomous Systems,2010,58(1): 46-67.
[94] Yang J, Wang X, Bauer P. V-Shaped Formation Control for Robotic Swarms Constrained by Field of View[J]. Applied Sciences-Basel,2018,8(11): 2120.
[95] LUO Q. DUAN H B. Distributed UAV flocking control based on homing pigeon hierarchical strategies[J]. Aerospace Science and Technology, 2017, 70(8): 257-264.
[96] QIU H X, DUAN H B. Pigeon interaction mode switch-based UAV distributed flocking control under obstacle environments[J]. ISA Transactions, 2017, 71(1): 93-102.
[97] TSITSIKLIS JN, ATHANS M. Convergence and Asymptotic Agreement in Distributed Decision Problems[J]. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control,1984,29(1): 42-50.
[98] Zhao Y X, Hao Y Q, Wang Q S, et al. Formation of multi-agent systems with desired orien-tation:a distance-based control approach[J]. Nonlinear Dynamics,2021,106(4): 3351-3361.
[99] Olfati-Saber R, Murray R M. Consensus Problems in Networks of Agents with Switching Topology and Time-Delays[J]. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control,2004,49(9):1520-1533.
[100] Jadbabaie A, Lin J, Morse A S. Coordination of Groups of Mobile Autonomous Agents Using Nearest Neighbor Rules[J]. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control,2003,48(6):988-1001.
[101] Ren W. Consensus Strategies for Cooperative Control of Vehicle Formations[J]. IET Control Theory & Applications,2007,1(2) :505-512.
[102] Zhang D, Xu Z H, Wang Q W, et al. Leader-follower H∞ consensus of linear multi-agent systems with aperiodic sampling and switching connected topologies[J]. ISA Transactions, 2017,68:150?159.
[103] Zhuang H C, Dong K L, Wang N, et al. Multi-Robot Leader Grouping Consistent Formation Control Method Research with Low Convergence Time Based on Nonholonomic Constraints[J]. Applied Sciences-Basel,2022,12(5): 2300.
[104] 郑维,张志明,刘和鑫,等.基于线性变换的领导-跟随多智能体系统动态反馈均方一致性控制[J].自动化学报,2022,48(10):2474-2485.
ZHENG W, ZHANG Z M, LIU H X, et al. Dynamic feedback mean square consensus control based on Linear transformation for Leader-follower multi-agent systems[J]. Acta Automatica Sinica, 2022,48(10):2474-2485. (in Chinese)
[105] Chen J X, Li J M. Globally fuzzy leader-follower consensus of mixed-order nonlinear multi-agent systems with partially unknown direction control[J]. Information Sciences,2020,523:184?196.
[106] Li G P, Wang X Y, Li S H. Finite-time consensus algo-rithms of leader-follower higher-order multi-agent systems with uncertain nonlinearities[J]. Journal of the Franklin Institute, 2020,357(16):11939?11952.
[107] 赵建霞,段海滨,赵彦杰,等.基于鸽群层级交互的有人/无人机集群一致性控制[J].上海交通大学学报,2020,54(09):973-980.
ZHAO J X, DUAN H B, ZHAO Y J, et al. Consensus Control of Manned-Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Swarm Based on Hierarchy Interaction of Pigeons [J]. Journal of Shanghai Jiaotong University,2020,54(09):973-980. (in Chinese)
[108] Huo M Z, Duan H B, Ding X L. Manned Aircraft and Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Heterogeneous Formation Flight Control via Heterogeneous Pigeon Flock Con-sistency[J]. Unmanned Systems,2021,09(03): 227-236.
[109] 李国飞,朱国梁,吕金虎,等.主-从多飞行器三维分布式协同制导方法[J].航空学报,2021,42(11):236-245.
LI G F, ZHU G L, LYU J H. et al. Three-dimensional distributed cooperative guidance law for multiple leader-follower flight vehicles[J]. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica,2021,42(11): 524926. (in Chinese).
[110] Wu Y Z, Liang Q P, Zhao Y Y, et al. Distributed estimation-based output consensus control of heterogeneous leader-follower systems with antagonistic interactions[J].Science China(Information Sciences),2023,66(03):305-306.
[111] Fan J R, Li D G, Li R P, et al. Analysis on MAV/UAV cooperative combat based on complex network[J]. Defence technology,2020,16(1):150–157.
[112] Fan J R, Li D G, Li R P. Evaluation of MAV/UAV collaborative combat capability based on network structure[J]. International Journal of Aerospace Engineering,2018,2018: 5301752.
[113] Chen J, Gao X G, Yu G H. Cooperative effect analysis of manned/unmanned aerial vehicle team based on fuzzy cognition map[C]//Proc. 2011 IEEE International Conference on Signal Processing, Communications and Computing (ICSPCC), Xi'an,China,2011:1–5.
[114] 韩月明,刘铁林,薛辉.基于灰色理论的有人/无人机协同作战效能评估[J].军事运筹与评估,2023,38(01):20-26.
HAN Y M, LIU T L, XUE H. Evaluation of Man-UAV cooperative combat effectiveness based on Grey Theory [J]. Military Operations Research and Assess-ment,2023,38(01):20-26. (in Chinese)
[115] 尹昊,侯婷婷,李东光.面向典型任务的有人/无人机协同效能评估[J].无人系统技术,2021,4(01):62-70.
YIN H, HOU T T, LI D G. Cooperative Effectiveness Evaluation of MAV/UAV for Typical Missions[J]. Un-manned Systems Technology,2021,4(01):62-70.(in Chinese)
[116] 王坦,杨森,齐晓慧,等.基于Hopfield网络的有人机/无人机协同作战效能评估[J].电光与控制,2021,28(10):80-84.
WANG T, YANG S, QI X H, et al. Effectiveness eval-uation of MAV/UAV cooperative operations based on Hopfield neural network[J]. Electronics Optics & Control, 2021,28(10):80-84. (in Chinese)
[117] Jia N P, Yang Z W, Yang K W. Operational Effective-ness Evaluation of the Swarming UAVs Combat System Based on a System Dynamics Model[J]. IEEE Access,2019,7:25209-25224.
[118] XIONG P S, LIU H, TIAN Y L. Mission effectiveness evaluation of manned/unmanned aerial team based on OODA and agent-based simulation[C]//Proc. of the 3rd International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Virtual Reality, 2019, 31 -37.
[119] 刘遵飞,邹波,陈续麟,等.有人与无人联合作战模式下的装备体系结构建模与效能评估[J].兵工学报,2022,43(S1):155-161.
LIU Z F, ZOU B, CHEN X L, et al. Architecture Mod-eling and Effectiveness Evaluation of Equipment Sys-tem under Manned and Unmanned Joint Operation Mode[J]. ACTA ARMAMENTARII,2022,43(S1):155-161. (in Chinese)
[120] 胡嘉悦,李广文,章卫国,等.面向有人/无人机协同远程作战的IVMS架构[J].航空学报,2022,43(03):467-478.
HU J Y, LI G W, ZHANG W G. et al. IVMS architec-ture for MAV/UAV cooperative long-range combat[J]. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica,2022,43(3): 325199.(in Chinese)
[121] 王新尧,曹云峰,孙厚俊,等.基于DoDAF的有人/无人机协同作战体系结构建模[J].系统工程与电子技术,2020,42(10):2265-2274.
WANG X Y, CAO Y F, SUN H J, et al. Modeling for cooperative combat system architecture of manned/unmanned aerial vehicle based on DoDAF[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics, 2020, 42(10):2265-2274. (in Chinese)
[122] CHEN Jun, QIU Xunjie, RONG Jia, et al. Design method of organizational structure for MAVs and UAVs heterogeneous team with adjustable autono-my[J].Journal of Systems Engineering and Electron-ics,2018,29(02):286-295.
[123] Simon Schwerd, Axel Schulte. Operator State Estima-tion to Enable Adaptive Assistance in Manned-Unmanned-Teaming[J]. Cognitive Systems Re-search,2021,67: 73-83.
[124] Shu Z, Wang W P, Wang R. Design of an Optimized Architecture for Manned and Unmanned Combat System-of-Systems: Formulation and Coevolutionary Optimization[J]. IEEE Access,2018,6: 52725-52740.
[125] 吴立尧,韩维,张勇,等.有人/无人机编队指挥控制系统结构设计[J].系统工程与电子技术,2020,42(08):1826-1834.
WU L Y, HAN W, ZHANG Y, et al. Structure design of command and control system for manned/unmanned aeriall vehicles formation[J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics, 2020, 42(8):1826-1834. (in Chinese)
[126] 彭辉,相晓嘉,吴立珍,等.有人机/无人机协同任务控制系统[J].航空学报,2008(S1):135-141.
PENG H, XIANG X J, WU L Z, et al. Cooperative mission control System of Manned Vehicle and Unmanned Aerial Vehicle[J]. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica,2008(S1):135-141. (in Chinese)
[127] 吴立珍,李远,彭辉,等.有人机/无人机协同任务指令集的设计与实现[J].系统仿真学报,2008,20(S1):514-521.
WU L Z, LI Y, PENG H, et al. Design and Implementation of the Instruction Set for Manned Vehicle-UAV Cooperative Missions[J]. Journal of System Simulation,2008,20(S1):514-521. (in Chinese)
[128] Lim Y X, Alessandro G, Roberto S, et al. Avionics human-machine interfaces and interactions for manned and unmanned aircraft[J].Progress In Aerospace Sciences,2018,102: 1-46.
[129] Xue H J, Zhang Q P, Zhang X Y. Research on the Applicability of Touchscreens in Manned/Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Cooperative Missions[J]. Sen-sors,2022,22(21): 8435.
[130] Roth G, Schulte A, Schmitt F. Transparency for a Workload-Adaptive Cognitive Agent in a Manned-Unmanned Teaming Application[J]. IEEE Transactions on Human-Machine Systems,2020, 50 (3):225-233.
[131] Levulis S J, DeLucia P R, Kim S Y. Effects of Touch, Voice, and Multimodal Input, and Task Load on Multiple-UAV Monitoring Performance During Simulated Manned-Unmanned Teaming in a Military Helicopter[J]. Human Factors,2018,60(8): 1117-1129.
[132] BRIAN RAU. Unmanned and Manned Aircraft Traf-fic Deconfliction Continues to Evolve[J]. Agricultural aviation,2021,48(2):12-15.
[133] Thipphavong David P, Johnson Marcus A, Refai Mo-hamad S, et al. Downstream Effects of Separation As-surance on Encounters Between Unmanned and Manned Aircraft[J]. Journal of Air Transporta-tion,2017,25(2): 39-50.
[134] Hu Y, Zhang W H. Modeling framework for analyzing midair encounters in hybrid airspace where manned and unmanned aircraft coexist[J].Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part G-Journal of Aerospace Engineering,2019,233(15): 5492-5506.
[135] Ribeiro M, Ellerbroek J, Hoekstra J. Review of Conflict Resolution Methods for Manned and Unmanned Aviation[J]. Aerospace,7(6): 1-37.
[136] Nakamura H, Matsumoto Y, Suzuki S. Flight Demon-stration for Information Sharing to Avoid Collisions between Small Unmanned Aerial Systems (sUASs) and Manned Helicopters[J]. Transactions of the Japan Society for Aeronautical and Space Sciences,2019,62(2): 75-85.
[137] Xia C Y, Yang C R, Xue K, et al. A Conflict Risk Analysis of MAV\UAV Flight in Shared Air-space[J].International Journal of Aerospace Engineer-ing,2021, 2021:1692896.
[138] Zhong Y, Yao P Y, Wan L J, et al. Optimal Placement of CRNs in Manned/Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Cooperative Engagement System[J]. KSII Transactions on Internet and Information Sys-tems,2019,13(1): 52-68.
[139] Jerry Ding, Jonathan Sprinkle, Claire J. Tomlin, et al. Reachability Calculations for Vehicle Safety During Manned/Unmanned Vehicle Interaction[J]Journal of guidance, control, and dynamics,2012(1): 138-152.
[140] 高骏峰,向旭. 雾海突袭无人机制导“低空利箭”[N]. 解放军报,2020-11-16(002).
GAO J F, XIANG X. Fog Sea raid UAV guidance "Low altitude Sharp Arrow" [N]. PLA Daily,2020-11-16(002).
[141] 赖文湧,廖晓彬,石芝鹏. 无人机引导直升机火力突击[N]. 解放军报,2022-04-28(002).
LAI W Y, LIAO X B, SHI Z P. UAV guided helicopter fire assault [N]. PLA Daily,2022-04-28(002).
[142] 央视网. 无人机+武装直升机=致命打击[EB/OL].北京：央视网, 2021. （2021-08-27）[2023-07-04]. http://v.cctv.com/2021/08/27/VIDEywwKkli0AzqateCNW2N2210827.shtml.
CCTV Network. UAV + helicopter gunship = Lethal strike [EB/OL]. Beijing: The CCTV network, 2021. (2021-08-27)[2023-07-04]. http://v.cctv.com/2021/08/27/VIDEywwKkli0AzqateCNW2N2210827.shtml.
[143] 新华网. 直升机无人机空地协同打击演练[EB/OL]. 北京：央视军事微博,2023. （2023-01-02） [2023-07-04]. http://www.xinhuanet.com/mil/2023-01/02/c_1211713645.htm.
Xinhua Net. Helicopter UAV Air-to-ground Coordinated strike Drill [EB/OL]. Beijing: CCTV military microblogging, 2023. (2023-01-02) [2023-07-04]. http://www.xinhuanet.com/mil/2023-01/02/c_1211713645.htm.

Coordinated Manned/Unmanned Aerial Warfare: Concepts, Technologies, and Challenges

PDF (PC)

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

References

Related Articles 15

Recommended Articles

Metrics

Comments

[1]	Bojian LIU, Aijun LI, Yong GUO, Changqing WANG. Fault-tolerant containment control for precise formation of UAVs with input saturation [J]. ACTA AERONAUTICAET ASTRONAUTICA SINICA, 2023, 44(9): 327414-327414.
[2]	Guanshan LIU, Jie LIU, Xinyuan WANG. Interception strategy for anti-cross-medium missile attacks [J]. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica, 2023, 44(21): 528873-528873.
[3]	Zhiqiang WEI, Zheming WENG, Yongzhao HUA, Xiwang DONG, Zhang REN. Formation-containment tracking control for heterogeneous unmanned swarm systems with switching topologies [J]. ACTA AERONAUTICAET ASTRONAUTICA SINICA, 2023, 44(2): 326504-326504.
[4]	WANG Lin, ZHANG Qingjie, CHEN Hongwei. Optimal control method for swarm systems formation with LQR performance index [J]. ACTA AERONAUTICAET ASTRONAUTICA SINICA, 2022, 43(S1): 726902-726902.
[5]	YANG Mingyue, SHOU Yingxin, TANG Yong, LIU Chang, XU Bin. Multi-quadrotor UAVs formation maintenance and collision avoidance control [J]. ACTA AERONAUTICAET ASTRONAUTICA SINICA, 2022, 43(S1): 726913-726913.
[6]	GUO Hongzhen, CHEN Mou. Safety formation control of quadrotor UAVs based on prescribed performance [J]. ACTA AERONAUTICAET ASTRONAUTICA SINICA, 2021, 42(8): 525789-525789.
[7]	WANG Li'nan, CAI Chuhan, LIU Guosheng, MA Bang, MA Xianjie. Electro-optical countermeasure simulation of fighter terminal based on effectiveness evaluation [J]. ACTA AERONAUTICAET ASTRONAUTICA SINICA, 2021, 42(8): 525834-525834.
[8]	LIU Deyuan, LIU Hao, Frank L LEWIS. Robust fault-tolerant formation control for tail-sitters [J]. ACTA AERONAUTICAET ASTRONAUTICA SINICA, 2021, 42(2): 324296-324296.
[9]	WANG Jing, GU Weibo, DOU Liya. Leader-Follower formation control of multiple UAVs with trajectory tracking design [J]. ACTA AERONAUTICAET ASTRONAUTICA SINICA, 2020, 41(S1): 723758-723758.
[10]	WU Yu, LIANG Tianjiao. Improved consensus-based algorithm for unmanned aerial vehicle formation control [J]. ACTA AERONAUTICAET ASTRONAUTICA SINICA, 2020, 41(9): 323848-323848.
[11]	YANG Bo, ZHAO Peilin, CAI Sanjun, ZHOU Shenglin, CHEN Chuan. Key technologies and design of new generation fighter canopy [J]. ACTA AERONAUTICAET ASTRONAUTICA SINICA, 2020, 41(6): 523465-523465.
[12]	SHI Xiaohang, ZHANG Qingjie, LYU Junwei. Formation control for linear swarm systems with time-varying delays based on free-weighting matrices [J]. ACTA AERONAUTICAET ASTRONAUTICA SINICA, 2018, 39(3): 321628-321628.
[13]	MA Peibei, LEI Ming, JI Jun. Control of multi-UAV cooperative formation with equality communication time-delay [J]. ACTA AERONAUTICAET ASTRONAUTICA SINICA, 2017, 38(S1): 721551-721551.
[14]	ZHOU Shaolei, QI Yahui, ZHANG Lei, YAN Shi, KANG Yuhang. Time-varying formation control of UAV swarm systems with switching topologies [J]. ACTA AERONAUTICAET ASTRONAUTICA SINICA, 2017, 38(4): 320452-320452.
[15]	LI Qing, YAN Juan, ZHU Jiaqiang, HUANG Tao, ZANG Jing. State of art and development trends of top-level demonstration technology for aviation weapon equipment [J]. ACTA AERONAUTICAET ASTRONAUTICA SINICA, 2016, 37(1): 1-16.