Special Topic: Reusable Launch Vehicle Technology

Prospects for fatigue durability and reliability of reusable launch vehicle structures

  • Mengqi GU ,
  • Jiacai ZHU ,
  • Wanlin GUO ,
  • Song XUE
Expand
  • 1.School of Mechanical Engineering,Tsinghua University,Beijing 100084,China
    2.College of Aerospace Engineering,Nanjing University of Aeronautics & Astronautics,Nanjing 210016,China
E-mail: wlguo@nuaa.edu.cn

Received date: 2022-11-23

  Revised date: 2022-12-07

  Accepted date: 2023-02-27

  Online published: 2023-03-17

Supported by

National Key Research and Development Program of China(2019YFA0705400);Natural Science Foundation of Jiangsu Province(BK20212008);State Key Laboratory of Mechanics and Control of Mechanical Structures(MCMS-I-0421K01);Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities(NJ2022002)

Abstract

Reusable launch vehicle is an important development direction of the carrier rocket technology in the present world. Traditional disposable rockets only need to complete a single launch mission and usually use a high static strength safety factor to ensure their structural reliability. For reusable launch vehicle that need to perform as many launch missions as possible to increase economic efficiency, structural fatigue durability and reliability are difficult to be covered by static strength design. This review analyzes the key factors which determine the fatigue life of rockets under the existing technology conditions and points out the development direction for improving the durability and reliability of reusable launch vehicle. Vibration loading is the main driving force of fatigue crack propagation in complex environment, and it is vital to suppress structural vibration. The fatigue problems of welding structures and metal additive manufacturing structures commonly used in launch vehicles are specifically analyzed. The current status of the durability and reliability of launch vehicle structures is then reviewed. Finally, a unified method of three-dimensional fatigue fracture is proposed to study the fatigue durability and reliability of reusable launch vehicle. This method can consider all the factors affecting the fatigue life, correlate the initial fatigue quality of the structure and the driving force of crack growth indicated by the detection signal with the fatigue life, and give reliability.

Cite this article

Mengqi GU , Jiacai ZHU , Wanlin GUO , Song XUE . Prospects for fatigue durability and reliability of reusable launch vehicle structures[J]. ACTA AERONAUTICAET ASTRONAUTICA SINICA, 2023 , 44(23) : 628299 -628299 . DOI: 10.7527/S1000-6893.2023.28299

References

1 李东, 李平岐. 长征五号火箭技术突破与中国运载火箭未来发展[J]. 航空学报202243(10): 527269.
  LI D, LI P Q. Technological breakthroughs of LM-5 and future developments of China’s launch vehicle[J]. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica202243(10): 527269 (in Chinese).
2 SCOLES S. Prime mover[J]. Science2022377(6607): 702-705.
3 郭万林, 邵忍平, 冯谦. 结构损伤监测的研究现状与展望[J]. 振动、测试与诊断200323(2): 79-85.
  GUO W L, SHAO R P, FENG Q. A review and prospect of damage detection in structures[J]. Journal of Vibration, Measurement & Diagnosis, 200323(2): 79-85. (in Chinese).
4 CANDY J V, CASE J E, FISHER K A, et al. Vibrational processing of a dynamic structural flight system: A multichannel spectral estimation approach[J]. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America2020147(4): 2694.
5 ELDRED K, ROBERTS W, WHITE R. Structural vibrations in space vehicles[M].Ohio: Aeronautical Systems Division, US Air Force, 1961.
6 陈劲松, 曾玲芳, 平仕良, 等. 大型火箭发射喷水降噪技术研究进展[J]. 导弹与航天运载技术2019(2): 94-100.
  CHEN J S, ZENG L F, PING S L, et al. Advancesof water suppression technology for large rocket launching noise[J]. Missiles and Space Vehicles2019(2): 94-100 (in Chinese).
7 李海波, 任方, 秦朝红, 等. 国外运载火箭起飞噪声减缓技术研究进展[C]∥北京力学会第二十五届学术年会会议论文集. 北京: 北京力学学会, 2019: 1330-1332.
  LI H B, REN F, QIN C H, et al. Research Progress of Launch Vehicle Takeoff Noise Mitigation Technology Abroad[C]∥Proceedings of the 25th Annual Academic Conference of Beijing Society of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics. Beijing: Beijing Society of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics, 2019: 1330-1332 (in Chinese).
8 HOLLKAMP J J, GORDON R W, SPOTTSWOOD S M. Nonlinear modal models for sonic fatigue response prediction: A comparison of methods[J]. Journal of Sound and Vibration2005284(3-5): 1145-1163.
9 OPPENHEIM B W, RUBIN S. Advanced Pogo stability analysis for liquid rockets[J]. Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets199330(3): 360-373.
10 OSSAI C I, BOSWELL B, DAVIES I J. Pipeline failures in corrosive environments—A conceptual analysis of trends and effects[J]. Engineering Failure Analysis201553: 36-58.
11 FREY M, HAGEMANN G. Flow separation and side-loads in rocket nozzles[C]∥Proceedings of the 35th Joint Propulsion Conference and Exhibit. Reston: AIAA, 1999.
12 ?STLUND J, DAMGAARD T, FREY M. Side-load phenomena in highly overexpanded rocket nozzles[J]. Journal of Propulsion and Power200420(4): 695-704.
13 何光宇, 李应红, 柴艳, 等. 航空发动机压气机叶片砂尘冲蚀防护涂层关键问题综述[J]. 航空学报201536(6): 1733-1743.
  HE G Y, LI Y H, CHAI Y, et al. Review of key issues on coating against sand erosion of aero-engine compressor blade[J]. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica201536(6): 1733-1743 (in Chinese).
14 ARAKERE N K, SWANSON G. Effect of crystal orientation on fatigue failure of single crystal nickel base turbine blade superalloys[J]. Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power2002124(1): 161-176.
15 ARAKERE N K. High-temperature fatigue properties of single crystal superalloys in air and hydrogen[J]. Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power2004126(3): 590-603.
16 郝贠洪, 邢永明, 杨诗婷. 风沙环境下钢结构表面涂层冲蚀行为与侵蚀机理研究[J]. 摩擦学学报201030(1): 26-31.
  HAO Y H, XING Y M, YANG S T. Erosion-wear behavior of steel structure coating subject to sandstorm[J]. Tribology201030(1): 26-31 (in Chinese).
17 CASTANIER M P, PIERRE C. Modeling and analysis of mistuned bladed disk vibration: Current status and emerging directions[J]. Journal of Propulsion and Power200622(2): 384-396.
18 ORSAGH R F, SHELDON J, KLENKE C J. Prognostics/diagnostics for gas turbine engine bearings[C]∥ 2003 IEEE Aerospace Conference Proceedings. Piscataway: IEEE Press, 2003.
19 CHILDS D W. Turbomachinery rotordynamics: Phenomena, modeling, and analysis[M]. New York: Wiley, 1993.
20 HASHIMOTO T, YOSHIDA M, WATANABE M, et al. Experimental study on rotating cavitation of rocket propellant pump inducers[J]. Journal of Propulsion and Power199713(4): 488-494.
21 谭永华, 黄道琼, 李锋. 液体火箭发动机结构中的疲劳问题[C]∥中国力学大会-2017暨庆祝中国力学学会成立60周年大会论文集. 北京: 中国力学学会, 2017: 1530-1542.
  TAN Y H, HUANG D Q, LI F, et al. Fatigue problems for the liquid rocket engine structure [C]∥Proceedings of the Chinese Congress of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics 2017 and the 60th Anniversary Conference of the Chinese Society of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics. Beijing: Chinese Society of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics, 2017: 1530-1542 (in Chinese).
22 ROMANO E. The structural dynamics analysis of the main injector LOX inlet tee and its redesign: NASA-CR-186764[R]. Washington, D.C.: NASA, 1989.
23 RYAN R S. A history of aerospace problems, their solutions, their lessons: NASA-TP-3653[R]. Washington, D.C.: NASA, 1996.
24 BROWN A. Structural dynamics of rocket engines[R]. Washington, D.C.: NASA, 2016.
25 GOETZ O, MONK J. Combustion device failures during space shuttle main engine development[R]. Washington, D.C.: NASA, 2005
26 BENASCIUTTI D, SHERRATT F, CRISTOFORI A. Recent developments in frequency domain multi-axial fatigue analysis[J]. International Journal of Fatigue201691: 397-413.
27 CARPINTERI A, SPAGNOLI A, VANTADORI S. A review of multiaxial fatigue criteria for random variable amplitude loads[J]. Fatigue & Fracture of Engineering Materials & Structures201740(7): 1007-1036.
28 MUC A. A fuzzy set approach to interlaminar cracks simulation problems[J]. International Journal of Fatigue200224(2-4): 419-427.
29 THIEDE R G, RICCIUS J R, REESE S. Life prediction of rocket combustion-chamber-type thermomechanical fatigue panels[J]. Journal of Propulsion and Power201733(6): 1529-1542.
30 MASUOKA T, RICCIUS J R. Life evaluation of a combustion chamber by thermomechanical fatigue panel tests based on a creep fatigue and ductile damage model[J]. International Journal of Damage Mechanics202029(2): 226-245.
31 SCHWARZ W, SCHWUB S, QUERING K, et al. Life prediction of thermally highly loaded components: Modelling the damage process of a rocket combustion chamber hot wall[J]. CEAS Space Journal20111(1): 83-97.
32 ASRAFF A K, APARNA R, KUMARESAN D, et al. Comparison of creep properties of four copper alloys and creep based stress analysis of a rocket engine combustion chamber[J]. Procedia Engineering201355: 45-50.
33 ASRAFF A K, SUNIL S, MUTHUKUMAR R, et al. Stress analysis & life prediction of a cryogenic rocket engine thrust chamber considering low cycle fatigue, creep and thermal ratchetting[J]. Transactions of the Indian Institute of Metals201063(2): 601-606.
34 BADLANI M, POROWSKI J, ODONNELL W J, et al. Development of a simplified procedure for rocket engine thrust chamber life prediction with creep: NASA-CR-165585[R]. Washington, D.C.: NASA, 1983
35 JANAKI RAM G D, VENUGOPAL REDDY A, PRASAD RAO K, et al. Microstructure and tensile properties of Inconel 718 pulsed Nd-YAG laser welds[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology2005167(1): 73-82.
36 HOBBACHER A F. Recommendations for fatigue design of welded joints and components[M]. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2016.
37 TENG T L, FUNG C P, CHANG P H. Effect of weld geometry and residual stresses on fatigue in butt-welded joints[J]. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping200279(7): 467-482.
38 BLAKEY-MILNER B, GRADL P, SNEDDEN G, et al. Metal additive manufacturing in aerospace: A review[J]. Materials & Design2021209: 110008.
39 FRAZIER W E. Metal additive manufacturing: A review[J]. Journal of Materials Engineering and Performance201423(6): 1917-1928.
40 GüNTHER J, KREWERTH D, LIPPMANN T, et al. Fatigue life of additively manufactured Ti-6Al-4V in the very high cycle fatigue regime[J]. International Journal of Fatigue201794: 236-245.
41 ZHOU Z P, HUANG L, SHANG Y J, et al. Causes analysis on cracks in nickel-based single crystal superalloy fabricated by laser powder deposition additive manufacturing[J]. Materials & Design2018160: 1238-1249.
42 TANG M, PISTORIUS P C. Oxides, porosity and fatigue performance of AlSi10Mg parts produced by selective laser melting[J]. International Journal of Fatigue201794: 192-201.
43 SANAEI N, FATEMI A. Defects in additive manufactured metals and their effect on fatigue performance: A state-of-the-art review[J]. Progress in Materials Science2021117: 100724.
44 OLIVEIRA J P, SANTOS T G, MIRANDA R M. Revisiting fundamental welding concepts to improve additive manufacturing: From theory to practice[J]. Progress in Materials Science2020107: 100590.
45 CHAUVET E, KONTIS P, J?GLE E A, et al. Hot cracking mechanism affecting a non-weldable Ni-based superalloy produced by selective electron beam melting[J]. Acta Materialia2018142: 82-94.
46 CHEN Y, LU F G, ZHANG K, et al. Dendritic microstructure and hot cracking of laser additive manufactured Inconel 718 under improved base cooling[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds2016670: 312-321.
47 UDDIN S Z, MURR L E, TERRAZAS C A, et al. Processing and characterization of crack-free aluminum 6061 using high-temperature heating in laser powder bed fusion additive manufacturing[J]. Additive Manufacturing201822: 405-415.
48 GU D D, HAGEDORN Y C, MEINERS W, et al. Densification behavior, microstructure evolution, and wear performance of selective laser melting processed commercially pure titanium[J]. Acta Materialia201260(9): 3849-3860.
49 TAN Q Y, ZHANG J Q, SUN Q, et al. Inoculation treatment of an additively manufactured 2024 aluminium alloy with titanium nanoparticles[J]. Acta Materialia2020196: 1-16.
50 GONG H J, RAFI K, STARR T, et al. The effects of processing parameters on defect regularity in Ti-6Al-4V parts fabricated by selective laser melting and electron beam melting[C]∥2013 International Solid Freeform Fabrication Symposium. Austin: University of Texas at Austin, 2013.
51 LU T, LIU C M, LI Z X, et al. Hot-wire arc additive manufacturing Ti-6.5Al-2Zr-1Mo-1V titanium alloy: Pore characterization, microstructural evolution, and mechanical properties[J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds2020817: 153334.
52 WU B T, PAN Z X, DING D H, et al. A review of the wire arc additive manufacturing of metals: Properties, defects and quality improvement[J]. Journal of Manufacturing Processes201835: 127-139.
53 AL-KETAN O, ROWSHAN R, AL-RUB R K ABU. Topology-mechanical property relationship of 3D printed strut, skeletal, and sheet based periodic metallic cellular materials[J]. Additive Manufacturing201819: 167-183.
54 FU J, QU S, DING J H, et al. Comparison of the microstructure, mechanical properties and distortion of stainless steel 316L fabricated by micro and conventional laser powder bed fusion[J]. Additive Manufacturing202144: 102067.
55 LI R D, LIU J H, SHI Y S, et al. Balling behavior of stainless steel and nickel powder during selective laser melting process[J]. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology201259(9): 1025-1035.
56 TANG Y T, PANWISAWAS C, GHOUSSOUB J N, et al. Alloys-by-design: Application to new superalloys for additive manufacturing[J]. Acta Materialia2021202: 417-436.
57 PANDEY P M, VENKATA REDDY N, DHANDE S G. Improvement of surface finish by staircase machining in fused deposition modeling[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology2003132(1-3): 323-331.
58 KHAIRALLAH S A, ANDERSON A T, RUBENCHIK A, et al. Laser Powder-bed fusion additive manufacturing: Physics of complex melt flow and formation mechanisms of pores, spatter, and denudation zones[J]. Acta Materialia2016108: 36-45.
59 MERCELIS P, KRUTH J P. Residual stresses in selective laser sintering and selective laser melting[J]. Rapid prototyping journal200612(5): 254-265.
60 ZAEH M F, BRANNER G. Investigations on residual stresses and deformations in selective laser melting[J]. Production Engineering20104(1): 35-45.
61 ALI H, GHADBEIGI H, MUMTAZ K. Processing parameter effects on residual stress and mechanical properties of selective laser melted Ti6Al4V[J]. Journal of Materials Engineering and Performance201827(8): 4059-4068.
62 WANG L F, JIANG X H, ZHU Y H, et al. An approach to predict the residual stress and distortion during the selective laser melting of AlSi10Mg parts[J]. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology201897(9): 3535-3546.
63 LIU Y, YANG Y Q, WANG D. A study on the residual stress during selective laser melting (SLM) of metallic powder[J]. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology201687(1): 647-656.
64 SIMSON T, EMMEL A, DWARS A, et al. Residual stress measurements on AISI 316L samples manufactured by selective laser melting[J]. Additive Manufacturing201717: 183-189.
65 MERTENS R, DADBAKHSH S, VAN HUMBEECK J, et al. Application of base plate preheating during selective laser melting[J]. Procedia CIRP201874: 5-11.
66 KERSTENS F, CERVONE A, GRADL P. End to end process evaluation for additively manufactured liquid rocket engine thrust chambers[J]. Acta Astronautica2021182: 454-465.
67 陈纪宏, 鲍福廷, 刘旸, 等. 固体火箭发动机金属壳体结构可靠性分析研究[J]. 计算机仿真201431(11): 33-37.
  CHEN J H, BAO F T, LIU Y, et al. Reliability analysis for solid rocket engine metal case structure[J]. Computer Simulation201431(11): 33-37 (in Chinese).
68 ZHANG Z, TENG Z J, WANG J Y, et al. Very high cycle fatigue behaviors of GH4169 superalloy at room and high temperatures[J]. Fatigue & Fracture of Engineering Materials & Structures202245(6): 1796-1806.
69 WALKER K. The effect of stress ratio during crack propagation and fatigue for 2024-T3 and 7075-T6 aluminum[M]∥Effects of Environment and Complex Load History on Fatigue Life, ASTM STP 462, American Society for Testing and Materials. West Conshohocken: ASTM International, 1970: 1-14.
70 SMITH K N, WATSON P, TOPPER T H. A stress-strain function for the fatigue of materials[J]. Journal of Materials19705: 767-778.
71 RADAJ D. Generalised neuber concept of fictitious Notch rounding[M]∥Advanced Methods of Fatigue Assessment. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer, 2013: 1-100.
72 MENEGHETTI G, LAZZARIN P. Significance of the elastic peak stress evaluated by FE analyses at the point of singularity of sharp V-notched components[J]. Fatigue & Fracture of Engineering Materials and Structures200730(2): 95-106.
73 RADAJ D, SONSINO C M, FRICKE W. Recent developments in local concepts of fatigue assessment of welded joints[J]. International Journal of Fatigue200931(1): 2-11.
74 MURAKAMI Y. Metal fatigue: Effects of small defects and nonmetallic inclusions[M]. 2nd ed. London: Academic Press, 2019: 64-66.
75 SONG L K, BAI G C, FEI C W. Probabilistic LCF life assessment for turbine discs with DC strategy-based wavelet neural network regression[J]. International Journal of Fatigue2019119: 204-219.
76 ZHU S P, HUANG H Z, SMITH R, et al. Bayesian framework for probabilistic low cycle fatigue life prediction and uncertainty modeling of aircraft turbine disk alloys[J]. Probabilistic Engineering Mechanics201334: 114-122.
77 IRWIN G R. Analysis of stresses and strains near the end of a crack traversing a plate[J]. Journal of Applied Mechanics195724(3): 361-364.
78 PARIS P, ERDOGAN F. A critical analysis of crack propagation laws[J]. Journal of Basic Engineering196385(4): 528-533.
79 WOLF E. Fatigue crack closure under cyclic tension[J]. Engineering Fracture Mechanics19702(1): 37-45.
80 ELBER W. The significance of fatigue crack closure[C]∥Damage Tolerance in Aircraft Structures Annual Meeting. West Conshohocken: ASTM International, 1971, doi: 10.1520/STP26680S .
81 NEWMAN J C. A crack-closure model for predicting fatigue crack growth under aircraft spectrum loading[M] West Conshohocken: ASTM International, 1981.
82 CHANG T, GUO W. Effects of strain hardening and stress state on fatigue crack closure[J]. International Journal of Fatigue199921(9): 881-888.
83 CHANG T, GUO W. A model for the through-thickness fatigue crack closure[J]. Engineering Fracture Mechanics199964(1): 59-65.
84 张田忠, 郭万林, 徐绯. 考虑应力状态的疲劳裂纹闭合分析[J]. 航空学报200122(1): 24-29.
  ZHANG T Z, GUO W L, XU F. Theoretical analysis of fatigue crack closure considering stress states[J]. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica200122(1): 24-29 (in Chinese).
85 郭万林. 复杂环境下的三维疲劳断裂[J]. 航空学报200223(3): 215-220.
  GUO W L. Three-dimensional fatigue fracture in complex environments[J]. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica200223(3): 215-220 (in Chinese).
86 NEWMAN J C JR. A crack opening stress equation for fatigue crack growth[J]. International Journal of Fracture198424(4): R131-R135.
87 GUO W. Three-dimensional analyses of plastic constraint for through-thickness cracked bodies[J]. Engineering Fracture Mechanics199962(4-5): 383-407.
88 NEWMAN J C JR, ANNIGERI B S. Fatigue-life prediction method based on small-crack theory in an engine material[J]. Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power2012134(3): 1.
89 YU P S, SHE C M, GUO W L. Equivalent thickness conception for corner cracks[J]. International Journal of Solids and Structures201047(16): 2123-2130.
90 YU P S, GUO W L. An equivalent thickness conception for prediction of surface fatigue crack growth life and shape evolution[J]. Engineering Fracture Mechanics201293: 65-74.
91 TANAKA K, NAKAI Y. Propagation and non-propagation of short fatigue cracks at a sharp Notch[J]. Fatigue & Fracture of Engineering Materials and Structures19836(4): 315-327.
92 YADOLLAHI A, MAHTABI M J, KHALILI A, et al. Fatigue life prediction of additively manufactured material: Effects of surface roughness, defect size, and shape[J]. Fatigue & Fracture of Engineering Materials & Structures201841(7): 1602-1614.
93 NEWMAN JR J C. FASTRAN-2: A fatigue crack growth structural analysis program[R]. Washington, D.C.: NASA, 1992.
94 MCDOWELL D L, GALL K, HORSTEMEYER M F, et al. Microstructure-based fatigue modeling of cast A356-T6 alloy[J]. Engineering Fracture Mechanics200370(1): 49-80.
95 XUE Y, PASCU A, HORSTEMEYER M F, et al. Microporosity effects on cyclic plasticity and fatigue of LENS?-processed steel[J]. Acta Materialia201058(11): 4029-4038.
96 WU Y T, ENRIGHT M P, MILLWATER H R. Probabilistic methods for design assessment of reliability with inspection[J]. AIAA Journal200240: 937-946.
97 GUO W L. Elastoplastic three dimensional crack border field—I. Singular structure of the field[J]. Engineering Fracture Mechanics199346(1): 93-104.
98 GUO W L. Elastoplastic three dimensional crack border field—II. Asymptotic solution for the field[J]. Engineering Fracture Mechanics199346(1): 105-113.
99 GUO W L. Elasto-plastic three-dimensional crack border field—III. Fracture parameters[J]. Engineering Fracture Mechanics199551(1): 51-71.
100 ZHU J C, GUO W, GUO W L. Surface fatigue crack growth under variable amplitude loading[J]. Engineering Fracture Mechanics2020239: 107317.
101 ZHU J C, XU L, GUO W L. The influence of bending loading on surface fatigue crack growth life[J]. International Journal of Fatigue2023167: 107285.
102 ZHANG J Q, ZHU J C, GUO W, et al. A machine learning-based approach to predict the fatigue life of three-dimensional cracked specimens[J]. International Journal of Fatigue2022159: 106808.
103 ZHU J, CAO J, GUO W. Three-dimensional fatigue crack growth based method for fatigue reliability of metallic materials[J]. International Journal of Fatigue2023173: 107697.
Outlines

/